Socialworkersspeaks on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterRSS Feed

Utah Social Worker: HBO’s “Big Love” Shows Only a Small Facet of Polygamist Way of Life

"Big Love" stars clockwise from upper left Jeanne Tripplehorn, Chloe Sevigny, Ginnifer Goodwin, and Bill Paxton. Inset, social worker Patricia Merkley.

“Big Love,” HBO’s critically acclaimed series about the trials and tribulations of a polygamous family in Utah, kicks off its fourth season Jan. 10 at 9 p.m. Eastern.

Utah social worker Patricia Merkley LCSW encourages folks to watch the program to learn about a little-known and often misunderstood segment of American society. Yet “Big Love” depicts just a tiny part of modern-day polygamy in Utah and other parts of the Western United States, she said.

“It can’t portray a whole population because in the intermountain West there are about 40,000 polygamists,” said Merkley, 52, who earned a masters degree in social work from the University of Utah and is a National Association of Social Workers member. “There are different groups and they emphasize different things.”

Merkley ought to know. She leads a two-member team of social workers that Utah hired to reach out and offer services to polygamous families in the vast, mountainous state, which covers 85,000 square miles. Polygamy is illegal in the United States but Utah decided to instead focus on crimes within such communities and work to improve relations with and extend services to polygamous families, who often live in isolated areas.

To read more about Utah’s position on polygamy, click here.

In “Big Love” actor Bill Paxton portrays “Bill Henrickson,” a member of a breakaway polygamy sect who tried but failed to live discretely with his three wives and eight children in suburban Salt Lake City. Merkley said some polygamist families are like the fictional Henricksons and try to blend into mainstream society.

However, there are other polygamists who live in fundamentalist religious communities or practice a communal way of life, she said.

The public has a high level of bias and anger toward polygamous families due partly to news coverage of children being removed from a polygamous community in Texas. However, Merkley said there is no research that indicates there is more domestic violence or child abuse in polygamous households.

The founding Mormons practiced polygamy but in 1890 the church banned men from having many wives so Utah could gain statehood. So although she is a Mormon Merkley said the practice of having multiple wives and large families is as alien to her as it is to most Americans. As a social worker she tries to treat her polygamous clients with respect and dignity.

“It was so vastly different for me. I have been working with them for six years and I still say the wrong things and make assumptions,” she said. “I’m still learning.”

Polygamous families deal with the same issues traditional families deal with except “everything is amplified” because you are dealing with multiple marital relationships, women and children in the same household, Merkley said.

“It is fascinating to hear just the added level of conflict and struggle when you have more than one wife cooking, when you have more than one wife disciplining the children, and more than one wife trying to spend the money in one way,” she said. “It’s really life accelerated. It is really intensified in every way.”

Merkley, who also works for the Family Support Center, runs a support group that allows women from polygamous families to talk about their issues and reach out for help and advice.  Utah also takes part in the Safety Net Committee, which began in 2003 and holds monthly meetings in Utah, Arizona and British Columbia. Government agencies, non-profits and interested members of the public consult the committee to ensure polygamous families have the same educational opportunities and access to police, safety and government services as the general public.

Merkley is also working with polygamous groups on a marriage manual specifically tailored to such families.

Even with her education, training and firm grounding in the Mormon faith, Merkley admits the task can be humbling.

“Oftentimes I’ve had to rewrite and rethink everything basic that I would use anywhere else,” she said. “I try to be respectful and they are patient and forgiving and say that just doesn’t work and this is why. Yeah, it’s an ongoing process that I’m hoping stays active and continues on.”

Social workers such as Patricia Merkley are committed to understanding and treating fairly people of all persuasions. To read the “National Association of Social Workers Standards for Cultural Competence in Social Work Practice” click here. You may also want to look at NASW’s Diversity and Cultural Competence issue fact sheet by clicking here.

|   Leave A Comment
Tagged as:

Advertisement

5 Comments

  1. I’m glad to read this cause I think some people might think its only entertainment. It is entertaining but mostly because I know real people live this type of life. I can only imagine as I could not share my husband.

  2. Patricia Merkley needs to drop the PC “respectfulness”. Polygamy leads to poverty, gender apartheid, inbreeding, isolation, sexual abuse of young girls and abandonment of young males. If you want to study a model of polygamous society, look no further than Muslims. Can anyone reasonably say Islam is not violent? It is no intellectual stretch to figure polygamy is a big, obvious reason.

  3. Polyamory, Polygamy, Poligany and Polyandry are just simply a different lifestyle. Yes there are problems in some closed groups but only because the are forced to be hidden away from the main stream. Therefore not open to public scrutiny. Love is multiplied not divided, if you have more than one child you don’t love each one less, you love them all the same. The same goes with wives,husbands, etc.

    A lot of Fundamental Muslims are whacked just like a lot of fundamental Christians are. ie Fred Phelps, Topeka KS. Having multiple wives has nothing to do with making Muslims violent as Nancy asserts, and Yes it was an obvious intellectual stretch for you hun. It is their religion mis interpreted and mis applied. And the training and indoctrination they receive as children.

    Polyamory is alive and well in all 50 states and US territories and growing by leaps and bounds. it is gaining wider acceptance all the time. As most alternative life styles are. Especially with programs like Big Love and Sister Wives. People are sick and tired of governmental interference in their interpersonal relationships, the are after all, personal. As long as children are not being harmed in the process. Which we discovered after the recent forcible government removal of 300 children. Turned out to be a misguided social workers fantasy.

    Live and let live, harm none, by thoughts, actions or deeds.

    David

  4. Let’s not be naive. While parents may strive to love all of their children equally and may even feel that they do, any family therapist can tell you about alliances and favoritism that occur within families. The same is true of multiple wives. Short-term, it is an admirable goal to reach out to women and children in polygamous groups, but studies show that the children and women in these family groups suffer physically and emotionally. The problems do not occur because society isolates them, but because they are self-isolating. Those who escape from these communities tell harrowing tales of physical, emotional and sexual abuse, exploitation of children and abandonment of adolescent sons. There is a principle that encourages them to “bleed the beast,” in other words, to bleed the government by not paying taxes and by taking whatever the system has to give, including food stamps and public assistance. Kody Brown and three of his wives (Sister Wives) have filed bankruptcy claims and they, too have used food stamps, yet they proclaim that they are self-supporting.

    It is time t hat we stop enabling behavior that is destructive to women and children.

  5. I admire this woman and the work she is doing. I am so intrigued and fascinated in this very population and helping them in a social work setting. As a student of social work after my internship I hope to find work in this field. This article inspired me to watch this show.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.